For mechanical keyboard enthusiasts, keycaps aren't just for typing—they're also a significant means of expression and achieving the best typing experience. With the growing desire for customization, a steady stream of new keycaps has entered the market. Among them, XDA keycaps have enjoyed considerable popularity due to their unique design and excellent typing feel. This article will cover in detail the uniqueness of XDA keycaps, their advantages and disadvantages, and how they compare to other keycap profiles.
What are XDA keycaps?
The XDA keycaps are an advanced version of the DSA keycaps. They retain the flat profile and rounded corners of the DSA keycaps, but are taller, making typing more comfortable and finger-friendly.
Main features of the XDA keycaps
-
Uniform profile: XDA keycaps have a consistently flat, uniform design across all keys, giving them a minimalist appearance.
-
Height: The height of XDA keycaps is between that of DSA and Cherry keycaps. This allows them to maintain the compact shape of a low-profile design while providing better finger grip and reducing fatigue during extended typing sessions.
-
Surface: The top surface of the XDA keycaps features a concave design. This not only provides an attractive appearance, but also, more importantly, a more comfortable typing experience, as the fingertips receive better grip and feedback when pressing.
Advantages of XDA keycaps
1. Pleasant typing experience
XDA keycaps offer a larger surface area, making typing particularly comfortable. At approximately 9 mm high, they're neither too high nor too low, allowing for balanced and comfortable use.
2. Beautiful appearance
The rounded corners and concave top design give the XDA keycaps an appealing appearance. They add a touch of aesthetic appeal to any keyboard and bring a unique elegance.
3. Personalization options
A variety of available spacebar lengths and special key shapes cover the individual needs of a wide variety of users and enable a keyboard design that optimally matches personal usage habits.
Disadvantages of XDA keycaps
1. Possible false stops
Since XDA keycaps don't have a graduated height, this can increase the likelihood of accidental keystrokes. Especially when switching from Cherry or OEM keycaps, some adjustment time is required to get used to the uniform profile.
2. Limited selection
There are comparatively fewer variants and sets of XDA keycaps on the market. As a result, users may encounter limitations in terms of colors, layouts, or special keys.
3. Adjustment period
Those used to keycaps with different height profiles may need some time to adjust to the specific height and typing feel of the XDA keycaps, especially with extended use.
DSA vs. XDA Keycaps
| feature | DSA keycaps | XDA Keycaps |
| Profile shape | Uniform height across all keys | Uniform height across all keys, approx. 1 mm higher than DSA |
| Key surface | Smaller surface area | Larger surface area |
| Typing feel | Slightly concave surface for finger guidance | Flat surface for stability |
| aesthetics | More angular with sharper corners | Rounded edges, modern look |
| adaptability | Highly adaptable, compatible with most keyboards | May require some adjustment period |
| Customizability | Available in many designs and colors | Often available in a wide range of designs and colors |
DSA and XDA keycaps are similar in shape: Both are spherical and have the same profile at every key position. However, DSA is slightly lower than XDA, and the key surface is smaller.
Those who prefer a stable typing feel will find XDA keycaps particularly appealing thanks to their elegant design and flat, uniform shape.
SDA vs. XDA Keycaps
| feature | SDA keycaps | XDA Keycaps |
| Profile shape | Sculpted, different heights | Uniform height across all keys |
| Key surface | Relatively small, less contact area for the fingers | Significantly larger surface, offers more finger contact |
| Typing feel | Can cause fatigue during longer typing sessions | Flat surface for stability, ideal for extended typing |
| aesthetics | Traditional, varied look | Modern, elegant look |
| Customizability | Limited selection | Often available in many designs and colors |
SDA keycaps have a thinner and shorter keycap with a smaller contact surface, which can be tiring during extended use. XDA keycaps, on the other hand, are taller and offer a larger contact area, making them more comfortable for longer typing sessions.
While XDA keycaps are particularly suitable for users who prefer more finger support and a stable typing feel, SDA keycaps are ideal for those who prefer a flat, low profile.
Cherry vs. XDA Keycaps
| feature | Cherry keycaps | XDA Keycaps |
| Profile shape | Sculpted with different heights per row | Uniform height across all keys |
| Key surface | Relatively small, less finger contact | Significantly larger, offers more finger contact |
| Typing feel | Smooth typing feel, but lower height can be tiring | Medium height with larger surface for better grip |
| aesthetics | Traditional look, edgy and clearly defined | Modern, elegant look with rounded edges |
| Customizability | Available in many designs and colors | Often available in a wide range of designs and colors |
With their sculpted design and varying heights for each row of keys , Cherry keycaps offer a more pronounced, ergonomic typing feel. However, those who prefer a consistent, flat surface—for gaming or a quieter typing experience, for example—will find XDA keycaps particularly comfortable due to their uniform profile and generous finger rest.
Who are XDA keycaps suitable for?
XDA keycaps are particularly suitable for users who value an attractive design and good value for money – especially if they are not particularly sensitive to accidental keystrokes.
However, for users accustomed to Cherry or OEM profiles, it may take some time to adjust to the flat, uniform profile of the XDA keycaps.
Where can I buy XDA keycaps?
Several well-known brands offer XDA keycaps. Here are some popular suppliers:
-
Keyreative – Known for a variety of unique XDA keycap sets with custom color combinations and designs.
-
MelGeek – Offers custom and themed XDA keycap sets.
-
YMDK – Affordable XDA keycaps in many colors and materials.
-
KBDfans – Carries high-quality custom XDA keycap sets.
-
DROP (formerly Massdrop) – Partners with designers to offer exclusive XDA sets through group buys.
FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions about XDA Keycaps
Are XDA keycaps compatible with all switches?
Yes, XDA keycaps are compatible with most mechanical switches.
Do XDA keycaps offer a better typing feel than other profiles?
It's a matter of taste. Some users appreciate the uniformity of XDA keycaps, while others prefer sculpted profiles like Cherry or SA.
Can you customize XDA keycaps?
Absolutely! They come in many colors and designs, allowing for extensive customization.
Are XDA keycaps good for typing?
Yes, for many users, they offer a comfortable typing experience. The flat surface allows fingers to glide effortlessly across the keyboard, which can reduce fatigue during long typing sessions. The sturdy construction also contributes to a pleasant sound profile.
Are XDA keycaps suitable for gaming?
XDA keycaps can be quite suitable for gamers. Their flat design allows for quick movement and easy access to all keys—ideal for action-packed games. However, some players prefer sculpted profiles for the stronger tactile feedback. It's best to try them out for yourself and find your favorite.
