When choosing a mechanical keyboard switch, you will come across three main types: Linear , Tactile and Clicky Switches . Each switch type has its own advantages and disadvantages that vary depending on your usage and preferences. In this article, we will help you find the right switch for your needs by explaining the differences and characteristics of these three switch types in more detail.
What are linear switches?
Linear switches offer a smooth and smooth typing experience without any haptic feedback or clicking sounds. When you press the key, it happens in one smooth motion with no resistance or "clocking". Linear switches offer a fast and smooth input, making them ideal for certain gaming styles and users.
Advantages:
- Fast typing experience : The lack of resistance or tactile feedback allows you to type quickly, making them ideal for fast-paced games like FPS (First Person Shooter).
- Lower noise : Since they do not produce any clicking noises, linear switches are significantly quieter than other switches.
- Smooth keystroke : The smooth pressing experience helps reduce fatigue as there are no unexpected jumps or resistance.
Disadvantages:
- Little haptic feedback : For users who prefer tactile feedback when typing, the lack of feedback could be perceived as a disadvantage.
- Unsatisfying for some : Some people find linear switches boring because there is no tactile confirmation that a key has been pressed.
What are tactile switches?
Tactile switches provide a noticeable "bump" or resistance in the middle of the key press, giving you confirmation that the key has been pressed. This type of switch provides a certain level of feedback without creating a clicking sound, making them a popular choice for heavy typists and programmers looking for precision and comfort when typing.
Advantages:
- Haptic Feedback : The resistance provides tactile confirmation that the key has been registered, which is especially helpful during long periods of typing or programming.
- Increased precision : Because you get tactile feedback, you're less likely to make accidental keystrokes.
- Quieter than clicky switches : Compared to clicky switches, tactile switches are relatively quiet, making them a good choice for the office or shared workspace.
Disadvantages:
- Not quite as fast as linear Switch : The resistance can make the typing process a bit slower, which can be a disadvantage in fast-paced gaming scenarios.
- Less smooth than linear switch : The noticeable resistance may be annoying for some, especially for users who prefer the smooth keystroke of the linear switch .
What are Clicky Switches?
Clicky switches are known for their loud "click" sounds and the tactile feedback they provide when the key is pressed. These switches offer both haptic feedback and audible signals, making them ideal for users who like both feedback and sounds. They are popular with many keyboard enthusiasts due to their distinctive sound and feedback.
Advantages:
- Audible and haptic feedback : The click sound and feedback give you clear confirmation that the key has been pressed. This is especially useful when you make a lot of keystrokes, for example when typing text.
- Fewer errors : Clear feedback helps prevent typos because you know exactly when a key has been registered.
- Fun and Satisfaction : For many, the audible and tactile feedback makes tapping on clicky switches a satisfying experience.
Disadvantages:
- Louder : The clicking sound can be annoying to others, especially in offices or quiet environments. If you travel a lot or work in a shared space, this could be problematic.
- Makes typing difficult in quiet environments : If you're looking for a quiet typing sound or are working in a quiet room, the loud click may be inconvenient.
Which key switch is right for you?
Finding the right mechanical switch is not always easy, as you never know exactly which switch you like best. Based on my experience, I would like to give you some suggestions that can help you choose. I hope they are helpful!
First of all, what is your primary purpose for using a mechanical keyboard? Is it primarily for gaming, work, or both? Once you determine this, we can narrow down the switch choices to better suit your needs.
If your main use is work, especially if you need to type text for long periods of time (e.g. when editing or programming), I recommend a linear switch . In my experience, linear switches are better suited for fast and large-scale typing.
If you use your keyboard frequently but don't need to type long text, a tactile or clicky switch might be a good choice. The choice will mostly depend on your environment and personal preference. If you prefer a quieter keyboard, tactile switches are a great option. However, if you want the click sound or don't mind the noise, clicky switches might be ideal for you.
Linear switches are also a great choice for gaming . They are particularly suitable for competitive games like CS: GO, where quick, responsive actions are required. With short lead times and light actuation, linear switches do not limit your actions per minute (APM).
However, if you mostly play single-player games, linear switches may not be the best choice. Single-player games often don't require high APMs, but rather more precise button actuation, which is why tactile switches are more suitable.
Summary:
-
Linear Switch : Best for competitive, fast-paced gaming and fast, large-area typing. Akko Fairy Switch and V3 Piano Pro Switch can be good choices.
-
Tackile Switch : Ideal for those who want a balance between feedback and noise, as well as for single player gamers. You can choose our V3 Cream Blue Pro Switch .
-
Clicky Switch : Ideal for keystrokers who like auditory feedback and the traditional typing feel, as well as single-player gamers. Try our latest clicky switch Akko Creamy Cyan Switch .
If you're still unsure about which switch is right for you, you can buy a switch tester . Many keyboard enthusiasts recommend using a switch tester to try out different switch types before committing to a full keyboard.
Other factors when choosing a switch
actuation force
The actuation force of a switch is measured in Newtons (N) and is typically between 0.45 and 0.7 N. The force required to activate a key can vary considerably. Choose a force that suits your typing style - lighter forces for faster typing and heavier forces for more deliberate keystrokes.
This choice directly affects the level of fatigue in your hands and wrists.
key travel & actuation point
Key travel is the distance a key on a keyboard travels before it is "depressed" after being pressed. Actuation point indicates how far a key must be pressed to register a keystroke. Keyboards with greater key travel require the keys to be pressed further.
Longer key travel (e.g. 3.5mm to 4mm) is ideal for those who prefer more noticeable key presses and feedback, while shorter key travel (e.g. 1.5mm to 2mm) is great for gaming or fast typing.
Early actuation (e.g. 1.0mm to 1.5mm) is ideal for fast typists and gamers who need quick response times. Later actuation (e.g. 2.0mm to 3.5mm) is suitable for those who prefer more discreet keystrokes and tactile feedback before activation.
Conclusion
There is no "best" switch, as every user has different preferences and requirements. Choosing between linear, tactile and clicky switches depends on your individual needs. If you're not sure which type of switch suits you best, you could try out different keyboards to find the right feel.
